Live Updates: Hourslong Strike in Israel Lays Bare Anger Over Hostage Killings

3 months ago 31
ARTICLE AD

Patrick Kingsley

Thousands of primary schools and several municipalities, transport networks and hospitals slowed or suspended operations across Israel on Monday as a partial labor strike to protest the government’s war strategy in Gaza laid bare the bitter schism among Israelis over their leaders’ reluctance to agree to a cease-fire with Hamas.

Union leaders agreed to halt the strike at 2:30 p.m. local time (7:30 a.m. Eastern), more than eight hours after it began, after a court said they had not given enough notice for the work stoppage to go ahead. Still, the strike and mass protests on Sunday were the broadest expressions of anti-government dissent since the war began, as union chiefs and business leaders joined forces to pressure Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to agree to a truce in Gaza that could facilitate the release of dozens of hostages still held there.

The strike came a day after the Israeli military announced that it had recovered the bodies of six hostages from Gaza, the latest captives to be found dead nearly 11 months after their abductions in the Hamas-led attacks that touched off the war.

Disruptions were widespread, even as the strike’s effects appeared to be limited in some sectors. Many schools and banks and some municipal offices closed or cut services. Departing flights were disrupted as workers went on strike at Ben-Gurion International Airport, the nation’s largest, while stevedores stopped unloading merchant ships. And medical staff at several hospitals cut back some non-urgent services.

But many municipalities continued work as normal, according to the representative body for local authorities, and some transport services returned by the afternoon. Some workers appeared reluctant to engage in a complete strike, while others rejected the premise of the strike altogether.

Here are the latest developments:

National fury: The brief work stoppage reflected the national outpouring of grief, anger and protest after the bodies of the six hostages were recovered in Gaza over the weekend. Advocates for the hostages and critics of Mr. Netanyahu argued that a cease-fire agreement could have saved their lives. Huge street protests across Israel erupted on Sunday night in which hundreds of thousands of demonstrators, according to organizers, called for a hostage release and a cease-fire.

Netanyahu’s calculations: The last strike on this scale, in March 2023, succeeded in forcing Israel’s prime minister to halt his deeply contentious effort to overhaul Israel’s judicial system. But his coalition partners generally oppose a compromise with Hamas, and Mr. Netanyahu has refused to agree to a truce that would involve Israel’s withdrawal from Gaza or lead to a permanent halt to the fighting, saying that either move could allow Hamas to survive and endanger Israel’s long-term security. Hamas has also refused to compromise, saying that it will not release more hostages without a permanent cease-fire.

Cease-fire talks: The Biden administration has mounted diplomatic pressure to break a deadlock in the negotiations involving Israel, Hamas and Egyptian and Qatari mediators. President Biden and Vice President Harris were scheduled to meet at the White House on Monday morning with the team representing the United States in the talks.

Hostages killed: The Israeli military said on Sunday that the six bodies found in Gaza were those of hostages who had been “brutally murdered” by Hamas. The Israeli Health Ministry later said that a forensic examination showed the hostages had been shot at close range. Hamas claimed, without providing evidence, that the hostages had been killed by the Israeli military. A funeral for one of hostages, Hersh Goldberg-Polin, an Israeli American dual citizen whose parents were among the most prominent campaigners for their release, was set for Monday in Jerusalem.

Polio in Gaza: Polio vaccinations continued for a second day in Gaza, after the Gazan Health Ministry said that more than 72,600 children had been vaccinated on Sunday in the central part of the territory. (United Nations agencies gave a higher figure, saying that nearly 87,000 had received the vaccine.) After Gaza last month recorded its first polio case in 25 years, Israeli forces and Hamas agreed to brief pauses in fighting to allow for a staggered, three-phase vaccination drive.

Adam Rasgon

Rachel Goldberg-Polin, Hersh’s mother, said at his funeral that she was put through unimaginable distress worrying about her son. “It was such a specific type of misery,” she said, calling her experience “an odyssey of torture.”

Holding back tears, she expressed some relief, saying her son was no longer in danger. “Finally you’re free,” she said.

Adam Rasgon

Thousands of people have gathered at Har HaMenuchot, a large cemetery in Jerusalem, for the funeral of Hersh Goldberg-Polin, a dual Israeli American citizen and one of six hostages who were found dead in a tunnel in southern Gaza on Saturday. President Isaac Herzog of Israel is among those attending. He is expected to deliver a eulogy, according to his office.

Adam Rasgon

In his eulogy, President Herzog expressed remorse that Israel had failed to protect Goldberg-Polin during the Hamas-led attacks last October and to bring him home alive. “I ask you for forgiveness,” he said.

Aaron Boxerman

Peter Lerner, an official with the Histadrut labor union, said it might attempt to call another strike. But it could face further legal challenges. The injunction ordering an end to the work stoppage on Monday called it “a political strike” rather than one based on economic grievances, which would have been entitled to special protections. Lerner said the union rejected that characterization.

Image

Demonstrators blocked a road near Kibbutz Yakum in Israel on Monday, calling for a deal for the release of hostages held in Gaza.Credit...Avishag Shaar-Yashuv for The New York Times

Scenes of protest mingled with business as usual on Monday across much of Israel, as a brief work stoppage in protest of the government’s war strategy in Gaza led thousands to walk off their jobs for several hours, while in some sectors the strike’s effects were less noticeable.

Scores of people staged a peaceful protest at an entrance to the town of Rehovot in central Israel in the morning as police officers directed traffic — significantly lighter than usual — around them. Many of the passing cars honked in support.

In Rehovot’s main street, several hundred protesters marched, many holding Israeli flags, others with yellow flags and yellow balloons. Most of the shops and cafes were closed. Almost all displayed posters of Nimrod Cohen, a soldier from Rehovot who was taken hostage in the Oct. 7 attacks and remains captive in Gaza.

In Jerusalem, signs of the strike were less apparent, with many markets, restaurants and stores open.

At Mahane Yehuda, a large open-air market in the city, nut purveyors, fruit and vegetable hawkers and bakeries were serving customers. Only a few shops were closed.

Yaakov Levi, 60, an owner of a wine store, said he identified with the protests in support of freeing the hostages and agreed that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu hadn’t done enough to secure their freedom. But he argued that striking was ineffectual.

“Shutting down the market won’t change the opinion of the government’s decision makers,” he said, surrounded by bottles of wine from Israel and abroad. “It will only make us as business owners suffer.”

Image

Protesters near Kibbutz Yakum in Israel on Monday.Credit...Avishag Shaar-Yashuv for The New York Times

The war, Mr. Levi said, had already exacted a major cost from businesses, especially with so many Israelis serving as reservists in Gaza.

Down the street at Nocturno, a popular restaurant, people were sipping hot coffee and biting into tomato-and-cucumber salads and shakshuka, eggs cooked in tomato sauce.

Near Mr. Netanyahu’s residence, dozens of protesters hoisted Israeli flags and signs bearing photos of hostages.

Shai Leifer, 37, a director of a Hebrew-language education program, said she was skipping work on Monday to demand that Mr. Netanyahu bring the hostages home.

“I came today to scream for the hostages,” she said. “We’ve had enough. We’re tired of it.”

A few dozen demonstrators also gathered near Kibbutz Be’eri, one of the Israeli communities hit hardest in the Oct. 7 attacks. Carmel Gat, one of the six Israeli hostages whose bodies were brought back from Gaza over the weekend, was abducted from Be’eri along with her sister-in-law Yarden; her mother, Kinneret, was killed. One of the demonstrators on Monday carried a sign begging forgiveness from Ms. Gat for Israel’s failure to save her.

In the city of Ra’anana in central Israel, dozens of protesters blocked a major intersection, holding signs bearing the faces of hostages. Tal Mayzels Atlas, an activist at the junction, shared a video of the protest showing Ruth Strum, the mother of hostages Yair and Eitan Horn addressing Israel’s leaders through a megaphone.

“I want my sons back,” she says in the video. “Why are you doing this to us? Bring them all back, now.”

Aaron Boxerman

An Israeli judge just issued a temporary injunction ordering a halt to the strike by Histadrut, Israel’s largest labor union, by 2:30 p.m. (7:30 a.m. Eastern). The judge, Hadas Yahalom, wrote that Israeli law obligated the union to provide prior notice of a strike — often as much as 15 days — rather than simply announcing it a day in advance.

Patrick Kingsley

The Histadrut union has said it will abide by the court’s decision. The strike will officially end in a few minutes.

Matthew Mpoke Bigg

Image

Arnon Bar-David, leader of Israel’s largest labor union, Histadrut, speaking at a protest outside the Ministry of Defense in Tel Aviv on Sunday.Credit...Gili Yaari/NurPhoto, via Getty Images

The labor union that called for the strike in Israel on Monday, Histadrut, has played a key role in recent Israeli politics. Most notably, it led strikes last year that challenged Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, forcing him to back off a contentious judicial plan.

Histadrut, or the General Organization of Workers in Israel, was also pivotal to the founding of the State of Israel. It was set up in 1920, at a time when trade unions were a critical vector of political and economic influence in many countries.

Its purpose in its early decades was both to serve the needs of workers at a time of Jewish immigration to what was then British-administered Palestine, and to lay the groundwork for the foundation of Israel as a state. It helped to establish the industrial, financial and economic institutions from which the nation emerged in 1948. The union’s leader in the early years, David Ben-Gurion, became Israel’s first prime minister.

The organization, the largest of its kind in Israel, now represents about 800,000 workers from 27 separate unions, according to its website. Its chairman, Arnon Bar-David, has held the post since 2019.

Mr. Bar-David, a longtime member of the union who also served as a major in the military reserves, in early 2023 joined other union chiefs, business leaders and military reservists to oppose a plan put in place by Mr. Netanyahu’s far-right government to limit the Supreme Court’s ability to strike down decisions by elected officials.

Histadrut organized a major strike that — along with disquiet in the military and mass protests that destabilized the economy — contributed to one of the biggest domestic upheavals in Israel in decades. The unrest prompted Mr. Netanyahu to suspend the judicial plan.

The deadly attack led by Hamas on Israel months later, and the ensuing Israeli military offensive in Gaza, moved the judicial issue to the background. But Histadrut again showed its influence by calling for the general strike on Monday, which, along with large street demonstrations the night before calling for a deal to free hostages from Gaza, amounted to the broadest expression of anti-government dissent since the war began.

Aaron Boxerman

A protracted Israeli military raid continued in the occupied West Bank, where soldiers remained deployed in the flashpoint city of Jenin. Many residents were still stuck in their homes without electricity or running water on the sixth day of the raid, and Israeli bulldozers had torn up roads, said Kamal Abu al-Rub, the city’s Palestinian governor. Israeli troops were also surrounding the main public hospital and inspecting people entering and leaving, he added.

Aaron Boxerman

A resident of Jenin reached by phone, Omar Obeid, 62, said he had fled the city Sunday evening with his children and many of his neighbors, walking through damaged streets. Eventually, they reached a relative’s home in nearby Ya’abad. “We tried to take a path that would avoid the army, but we still were risking our lives,” he said.

Image

Credit...Ronaldo Schemidt/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Hiba Yazbek

The Palestinian Health Ministry in Ramallah said that 29 people had been killed across the occupied West Bank since the raids began last Wednesday. It said those killed included five minors. Militant groups have claimed some of the dead as members.

Hiba Yazbek

In Gaza, a polio vaccination campaign entered its second day, after no major disruptions were reported on Sunday. The Gazan Health Ministry said more than 72,600 children had been vaccinated in the central part of the territory. The World Health Organization and UNRWA, the main U.N. agency aiding Palestinians in Gaza, gave higher figures, saying that nearly 87,000 children had received the vaccine on the first day of the drive.

Hiba Yazbek

U.N. agencies and others are attempting to vaccinate nearly 640,000 children under 10 in a three-phase campaign, after Gaza last month recorded its first polio case in 25 years. Israeli forces and Hamas have agreed to pause fighting for several hours each day in the areas where vaccinations are going on.

Image

Credit...Eyad Baba/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Image

Passengers checking flight times at Ben-Gurion International Airport in Tel Aviv on Monday. Workers at the airport said they would strike for part of the day.Credit...Sergey Ponomarev for The New York Times

Israel’s main labor union, Histadrut, called for a general strike on Monday to put pressure on the Israeli government to make a cease-fire deal with Hamas in order to secure the release of the dozens of hostages remaining in Gaza.

By early afternoon, it appeared to be the largest work stoppage in Israel since the war began, though not as widespread as some previous strikes the union had organized. Here are some sectors of the economy that are participating in the work stoppage, and some that aren’t:

Workers at Ben-Gurion International Airport, the nation’s largest, went on strike for part of the day, reducing the number of departing flights. Shortly after noon local time (5 a.m. Eastern), a spokesperson for the airport said departures had resumed.

Egged, Israel’s largest public bus transit company, said services were disrupted as some employees walked off. The company itself was not on strike, but some of its drivers were members of the Histadrut union, which is spearheading the work stoppage, said Inbal Klein Sova, an Egged spokeswoman.

Staff of the Jerusalem light rail network walked off the job in the morning, but the network said shortly after noon that it had returned to regular operations.

Thousands of primary schools ended their classes at 11:45 a.m. as a result of the strike, according to Gali Gabay, a media consultant for the Israel Teachers’ Union. Teachers were not striking, but other staff members stayed home, forcing the schools to close early, Ms. Gabay said.

Bank Hapoalim, one of the largest banks in Israel, said it was joining the strike and closed its branches on Monday. It said online transactions could still be made and that its telephone banking service was working in a limited capacity.

Bank Leumi, another major bank chain, took a similar approach.

Some hospitals have reduced non-urgent and outpatient services, while maintaining full emergency treatment and care for urgent cases. “We never, ever have a full-scale strike where we close the hospital — that would never happen,” said David Ratner, a spokesman for Rambam Medical Center, a major hospital in northern Israel.

Two hospitals in Jerusalem run by the Hadassah Medical Center have not joined the strike. “We don’t want to make it difficult for people who have been waiting weeks for appointments,” said Hadar Elboim, a spokeswoman for the hospitals.

Most local municipalities in Israel have chosen not to join the strike, according to Sivan Bahat, the spokeswoman for the Federation of Local Authorities. The decision not to strike, or to participate only partially, stemmed largely from a desire to avoid disruption to the education system a day after schools reopened following the summer break, she said. Tel Aviv City Hall was striking until noon, while Jerusalem’s municipal services were working as usual.

Instead of striking, many local councils are holding special sessions in solidarity with the families of hostages still held in Gaza, inviting the relatives of captives to come and speak at council meetings marking the day of protest.

Workers at the Haifa port, one of the five major ports in Israel, have joined the strike. They have stopped loading and unloading ships at the port until this evening, according to Zohar Rom, a spokesman for the Haifa Port Company. The effect of the strike will be limited unless it extends into a second day, Rom said.

Several entertainment companies have joined the strike, including Israel’s largest zoo, the Ramat Gan Safari, and the Batsheva Dance Company, a world-famous dance troupe that shut its offices in Tel Aviv.

Isabel Kershner

While most of those protesting or striking on Monday are critical of the Israeli government, some of its supporters are also taking to the street. A few dozen right-wing activists and relatives of Israeli soldiers who have been killed in battle rallied this morning outside the prime minister’s office in Jerusalem. Led by members of an organization known as the Forum for Families of Fallen Heroes, they called for increased military pressure on Gaza “until victory” and chanted that the strike called by the Histadrut labor union was “a prize for Hamas.”

Avishag Shaar-Yashuv

Avishag Shaar-Yashuv

Photographing in Israel

Protesters blocked a road near Kibbutz Yakum in central Israel, calling for a deal for the release of hostages held in Gaza.

Image

Credit...Avishag Shaar-Yashuv for The New York Times

Isabel Kershner

A hearing is underway at Israel’s national labor court, after the government asked for a temporary injunction against the general strike called by Histadrut, the country’s largest labor union. The government said in its petition that the strike was political and not related to a labor dispute.

Isabel Kershner

At noon local time, Israel’s Supreme Court will hear a separate petition against the strike by a group representing some pro-government families of hostages in Gaza.

Andrés R. Martínez

The strike will likely bring widespread disruptions. Schools, hospitals and municipal offices across the country are set to close or cut services. In Jerusalem, the light-rail network will be closed until noon. And workers at Ben-Gurion International Airport, the nation’s largest, have said they will strike for part of the day.

Image

Credit...Sergey Ponomarev for The New York Times

Mike Ives

The hostage killings have added pressure on Israel and its allies to reach a deal with Hamas over hostages that remain in Gaza. On Monday morning in Washington, President Biden and Vice President Harris are scheduled to meet in the White House Situation Room with the team representing the United States in hostage-deal negotiations.

Patrick Kingsley

The labor strike in Israel has started, said Peter Lerner, a senior official at Histadrut, the nation’s largest labor union.

Mike Ives

Defense Secretary Lloyd J. Austin III said on social media that he had called his Israeli counterpart to convey his “deepest condolences and outrage at Hamas’s vicious murder of six hostages.” He also called for a deal “to secure the release of the remaining hostages.”

Patrick Kingsley

Image

Protesters in Tel Aviv on Sunday night.Credit...Avishag Shaar-Yashuv for The New York Times

The expected labor strike in Israel on Monday reflects the scale of a dispute within Israeli society about whether Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu should continue to prioritize the destruction of Hamas over the release of Israeli hostages held in Gaza.

Through months of cease-fire negotiations, Mr. Netanyahu has refused to agree to a truce that would involve Israel’s withdrawal from Gaza or lead to a permanent halt to the fighting, saying that either move could allow Hamas to survive and endanger Israel’s long-term security. As a result, Hamas has also refused to compromise, saying that it will not release more hostages without a permanent cease-fire.

That standoff has prompted fury among many Israelis who want the hostages to be released even if it keeps Hamas in power in Gaza, fearing that the hostages will most likely die if they stay in the enclave for much longer.

The dispute reached a crescendo over the weekend after that fear came to pass: The Israeli military said it had found the bodies of six hostages who were killed recently by their captors as Israeli soldiers advanced toward the underground jail where they were held. Israel’s health ministry said that a forensic examination showed the hostages had been shot at close range sometime between Thursday and Friday morning.

Hamas said in a statement that the hostages were killed by the Israeli military.

It was unclear what effect, if any, the protests and planned strikes would have on Mr. Netanyahu. His right-wing base and far-right coalition allies say that it is better to avoid what they see as a flawed cease-fire deal, even if it would save the lives of some of the hostages. Some members of Mr. Netanyahu’s coalition have threatened to collapse the government if the deal goes ahead, and only one senior minister, Yoav Gallant, has pressed for an agreement.

Still, the last strike on this scale, in March 2023, succeeded in forcing Mr. Netanyahu to halt his deeply contentious effort to overhaul Israel’s judicial system. Seventeen months later, protesters hoped to achieve a similar result.

Roughly 250 people were abducted and taken to Gaza during Hamas’s raid on Israel at the start of the war on Oct. 7.

More than 100 of them were freed in a temporary cease-fire in November, while eight have been rescued alive during Israeli rescue operations that have cost the lives of hundreds of Palestinians.

The bodies of several hostages have also been found and repatriated by the Israeli military. Israeli soldiers shot and killed three others in December, after the hostages waved a white flag.

More than 60 living hostages, and the bodies of about 35 other hostages believed to be dead, are still in Gaza, according to the Israeli authorities.

Video

Video player loading

After the recovery of six hostages that the Israeli military said had been killed by Hamas, demonstrators filled the streets of Tel Aviv demanding that the government do more to bring the remaining hostages home.CreditCredit...Sergey Ponomarev for The New York Times

Protesters flooded the streets of Israeli cities on Sunday in mass demonstrations demanding that the government immediately accept a deal for the release of hostages held in Gaza. The furious protests, some of the largest the country has seen over months of failed negotiations, came after the Israeli military announced that six of the hostages had recently been killed in Gaza.

In Tel Aviv, protest organizers put the number of people in the hundreds of thousands. Hostage families and a crowd of supporters carried six prop coffins in a march through the city. They swarmed in front of the Israeli military headquarters and clashed with the police on a major highway.

In Jerusalem, the Israeli police fired skunk water, a noxious crowd control weapon, and forcefully removed a crowd of hundreds who rallied at the city’s main entrance. In smaller cities too, including Rehovot, in central Israel, people blocked traffic and chanted, “We want them back living, not in coffins!”

Video

transcript

transcript

Protesters in Jerusalem Demand an Immediate Hostage Deal

Israelis demonstrated outside Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office after the military recovered the bodies of six killed hostages from a tunnel underneath Rafah, Gaza.

“We’re grieving the death of six hostages. They should have come back alive. They could have come back alive. We need a deal now.” “We demand the deal to be right now. That’s why we’re marching for. That’s what we’re shouting for. There are many family members of the hostages here, saying words against the government, and calling: ‘Just bring them home.’”

Video player loading

Israelis demonstrated outside Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office after the military recovered the bodies of six killed hostages from a tunnel underneath Rafah, Gaza.CreditCredit...Ronen Zvulun/Reuters

The national uproar built on months of protests and increasingly aggressive actions by the families of many hostages, who have been attempting to pressure Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel to accept a deal to little avail.

The frustration of the families, who have accused Mr. Netanyahu of sacrificing their loved ones for his own political gain, appeared to reach a boiling point on Sunday after the Israeli military said it had recovered the bodies of six hostages killed in Gaza. The Israeli health ministry said they had been shot at close range sometime between Thursday and Friday morning.

Their blood was on the hands of the Israeli government, said the Hostages and Missing Families Forum, a group that represents some of the relatives, and it called on the public to “bring the nation to a halt.”

The message was echoed by Israel’s largest labor union, which declared a strike beginning Monday morning, and by Yair Lapid, the Israeli opposition leader.

The Families Forum said hundreds of thousands of people were protesting around the country on Sunday evening, but it was not possible to verify the figure. The Israeli police declined to provide any estimates of crowd sizes.

More protests were planned for Monday, the Families Forum said on social media.

Image

People attend a candlelight vigil in Jerusalem accompanied by prayers for the killed Israeli hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin.Credit...Ahmad Gharabli/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Several family members of the hostages directed their anger squarely at Mr. Netanyahu as they agitated for public action.

“Whoever accepts the murder of civilians for the Prime Minister should stay home,” Gil Dickmann, whose cousin Carmel Gat was one of the hostages found dead over the weekend, said on the social media platform X. “Those who don’t: in memory of Carmel, take to the streets — stop the abandonment, bring the state to a halt, get a deal.”

Jonathan Dekel-Chen, whose son Sagui is still held in Gaza, said in an interview that Mr. Netanyahu was “not only endangering our national security by refusing to complete this negotiated settlement, he’s also tearing apart this country by its seams. The country is aware that this government doesn’t exist for the service of the country but the service of itself.”

In Tel Aviv, where some of the largest crowds gathered, tensions escalated as night fell. Protesters blocked the main highway, pushed through security barricades and lit bonfires in the streets while the Israeli police carried out violent detentions and fired water cannons into the crowd. Naama Lazimi, a member of the Israeli Parliament, said on social media that the police had also thrown stun grenades at a close range, knocking her to the ground.

After hours of demonstrations, the Israeli police said it had arrested 29 people in Tel Aviv and cleared the highway. Five protesters were also arrested in Jerusalem, and two in Haifa, according to police officials.

Protesters expressed a mix of grief and rage, many carrying photos of the hostages and waving yellow ribbons in solidarity.

Shiraz Angert, a 23-year-old design student who was protesting in Jerusalem, wore a shirt bearing the photo of Hersh Goldberg-Polin, one of the hostages whose bodies were recovered on Saturday. “It was possible to save them in a deal,” she said. “These are people who were sacrificed because we didn’t do enough.”

In Tel Aviv, Dan Levinson, a 59-year-old high school teacher, said he hoped the night’s protest would be a watershed moment.

“I feel that tonight is the last chance for a turning point — people out in the streets tonight understand that what we have not been able to achieve so far into the war, we will not be able to ever reach unless a decision is made,” he said.

“If it does not happen now,” he added, “it never will.”

Amelia Nierenberg

Image

Clockwise from top left: Carmel Gat, Eden Yerushalmi, Hersh Goldberg-Polin, Ori Danino, Almog Sarusi and Alexander Lobanov, in photos released by the Hostages and Missing Families Forum.Credit...The Hostages and Missing Families Forum, via Associated Press

Tributes poured in on Sunday for the six hostages who were found dead in southern Gaza over the weekend.

The hostages, who the Israeli military said had been “brutally murdered” by Hamas, ranged in age from 23 to 40. Five had been at a dance music festival in southern Israel when they were taken captive during the Oct. 7 attack on Israel by Hamas and its allies; a sixth was taken from the village of Be’eri.

The Hostages and Missing Families Forum, a group of their relatives, identified the dead as Carmel Gat, Eden Yerushalmi, Hersh Goldberg-Polin, Alexander Lobanov, Almog Sarusi and Ori Danino. It also provided ages.

More than 60 living hostages, and the bodies of about 35 other hostages believed to be dead, are still in Gaza, according to Israeli authorities.

Here is what we know about the six whose deaths were confirmed on Sunday.

Mr. Goldberg-Polin was a dual Israeli American citizen who was taken hostage from the festival in southern Israel on Oct. 7. His mother, Rachel Goldberg-Polin, had traveled the world since, advocating the release of the hostages.

“Hersh is a happy-go-lucky, laid-back, good-humored, respectful and curious person,” she said last month, when she spoke at the Democratic National Convention with her husband, Jon.

“He is a civilian,” she added. “He loves soccer, is wild about music and music festivals, and he has been obsessed with geography and travel since he was a little boy.”

Mr. Goldberg-Polin was born in Berkeley, Calif. His family moved to Israel when he was in elementary school. Grievously injured during the attack, Mr. Goldberg-Polin lost part of his left arm and was last seen in a video released by Hamas in April.

President Biden was among those who expressed condolences to Mr. Goldberg-Polin’s family. “I am devastated and outraged,” Mr. Biden said in a statement, adding, “He planned to travel the world.”

Ms. Gat lived in Tel Aviv but was staying at her parents’ house in Be’eri, a kibbutz near the Gaza border, when she was taken hostage on Oct. 7. Her mother, Kinneret Gat, was killed in the attacks.

“Carmel was an occupational therapist, full of compassion and love, always finding ways to support and help others,” the forum wrote in a post on X. “She loved solo travel, meeting new people, live rock music concerts, and was particularly fond of Radiohead.”

Haaretz published a profile of Ms. Gat in January that said her closest friends had been holding regular yoga classes in her honor in Tel Aviv in what has become known as “Hostage Square.”

They also created a Spotify playlist of her favorite songs, Haaretz reported, calling it “a humorous, eclectic mix.”

“I remember us coming back to the kibbutz on weekends, putting music on and dancing,” Adi Zohar, a classmate, told the news outlet. “That’s her. Making a party out of things. Taking it easy.”

On Sunday, a cousin, Gil Dickmann, posted a photograph on X of a young Ms. Gat, wearing a pink shirt and holding a young baby, grinning at the camera. “Sorry Carmeli,” he wrote, adding, “If only you saw how your friends fought to get you back alive.”

Mr. Lobanov, who went by Alex, lived in the southern Israeli city of Ashkelon, according to the forum.

It said that he was working as a bar manager at the festival when the attack began and that witnesses said Mr. Lobanov helped evacuate people.

He and his wife, Michal, had two children: Tom, who is 2, and Kai, who is 5 months old and was born when Mr. Lobanov was in captivity in Gaza, Haaretz reported.

Mr. Lobanov also held Russian citizenship, according to Russia’s ambassador to Israel, Anatoly Viktorov.

“We mourn together with the entire family,” he said in a statement.

Ori Danino was from Jerusalem and was planning to study electrical engineering, Haaretz reported.

The oldest of five children, Mr. Danino had escaped the music festival but had gone back to help other people when he was captured, the Hostages and Missing Families Forum wrote on X.

“He was a fighter,” his partner, Liel Avraham, said on Israeli radio after learning of his death, The Jerusalem Post reported Sunday. She called him a “hero” who “excelled in everything he did.”

Ms. Avraham had posted about Mr. Danino on social media during his captivity. On April 7, she shared a picture of him kissing her on Instagram and in the caption teased him for losing to her at Backgammon and for letting his morning alarm ring.

Four weeks ago, she posted a photo of the two of them with the caption: “I’m waiting for you.”

Mr. Sarusi was from Ra’anana, a city north of Tel Aviv, according to Haaretz. It said he was at the music festival with his longtime girlfriend and had stayed by her side after she was wounded in the attack.

She died, and he was captured.

The Hostages and Missing Families Forum described him on X as “a vibrant, positive person who loved traveling around Israel in his white jeep with his guitar.”

Ms. Yerushalmi was “a vibrant young woman with many friends and hobbies,” the Hostages and Missing Families Forum wrote on X. “Eden loved spending summer days at the beach playing paddleball, attending parties, and was studying to become a Pilates instructor.”

In November, Ms. Yerushalmi’s sisters lit candles for her in New York City at the gravesite of a major spiritual leader in Judaism. They giggled at the time, trying to explain her nickname — “Opossum” — an old inside joke the sisters could no longer recall. Relatives of Ms. Yerushalmi had also traveled to Paris and Washington to press for the release of the hostages.

In a video posted in April, Ms. Yerushalmi’s sisters said she was a waitress in Tel Aviv who loved to make TikTok videos, rode a motorcycle and was “always the life of the party.”

“She’s very friendly,” they said in another video, posted in July. “She lives life to the fullest.”

Aaron Boxerman, Gabby Sobelman and Myra Noveck contributed reporting.

Vivek ShankarGabby Sobelman

Image

Rachel Goldberg, the mother of Hersh Goldberg-Polin, who was kidnapped on Oct. 7, at a protest last week in Israel near the border with the Gaza Strip.Credit...Amir Levy/Getty Images

The Israeli military said on Sunday that six bodies found in Gaza were hostages who had been “brutally murdered” by Hamas, setting off a wave of nationwide grief mixed with anger.

Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari, the military’s chief spokesman, said the bodies had been recovered a day earlier from a tunnel underneath the city of Rafah, in southern Gaza, close to where a seventh hostage, Farhan al-Qadi, was found alive last week.

“They were brutally murdered by Hamas terrorists a short time before we reached them,” Admiral Hagari said.

Israel’s health ministry said later on Sunday that a forensic examination showed the hostages had been shot at close range sometime between Thursday and Friday morning.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he was “shocked to the depths” of his soul by what he called the “coldblooded murder” of the hostages.

“The heart of the entire nation is torn,” he said in a statement.

In an initial statement, Hamas did not directly address the accusations, but said responsibility for the deaths lay with Israel, which it blamed for the lack of an agreement to stop the fighting in Gaza. Hamas later claimed in a separate statement, without providing evidence, that the hostages were killed by the Israeli military’s bullets.

Some people in Israel also angrily blamed the government for the deaths, calling for protests over the government’s inability to secure a deal to bring the hostages home.

Israeli military officials had said on Saturday that six bodies were found during a military operation, without specifying whether they were hostages’ bodies.

Lt. Col. Nadav Shoshani, a spokesman for the Israeli military, said Sunday on CNN that the grim discovery was not the result of a “specific mission to release hostages,” but that Israeli forces had “some idea of hostages being held in the area.”

The dead were identified as Carmel Gat, Eden Yerushalmi, Hersh Goldberg-Polin, Alexander Lobanov, Almog Sarusi and Ori Danino. They ranged in age from 23 to 40, according to a group representing families of hostages.

Five of those captured had been at a dance music festival in southern Israel. The sixth, Ms. Gat, was taken from the nearby village of Be’eri.

Before the Israeli military’s announcement, President Biden issued a statement saying that Israel had found the bodies of six hostages, identifying one as Mr. Goldberg-Polin, a dual Israeli American citizen whose parents had campaigned around the world for the release of the captives.

“I am devastated and outraged. Hersh was among the innocents brutally attacked while attending a music festival for peace in Israel,” Mr. Biden said. “He lost his arm helping friends and strangers during Hamas’s savage massacre. He had just turned 23.”

Mr. Biden vowed to keep working toward an agreement to secure the release of the hostages. But he also issued a warning: “Make no mistake, Hamas leaders will pay for these crimes.”

Mr. Goldberg-Polin was among the roughly 250 people who were abducted by Hamas and its allies during the Oct. 7 attack on Israel. He was last seen in a video released by Hamas in April.

On Sunday, the Goldberg-Polin family confirmed his death “with broken hearts.”

The Israeli military said that the bodies of the six hostages were returned to Israeli territory.

More than 60 living hostages, and the bodies of about 35 other hostages believed to be dead, are still in Gaza, according to Israeli authorities.

Adam Rasgon contributed reporting.

Read Entire Article