‘Mistletoe Murders’ Renewed For Season 2 By Hallmark Media

EXCLUSIVE: Mistletoe Murders is returning for a second season on Hallmark+.

The “holiday whodunnit” stars Sarah Drew (Grey’s Anatomy) as Emily Lane, a small-town shop owner with a secret past. The series from Lionsgate Canada and Headspinner Productions also features Peter Mooney (Rookie Blue) as local detective Sam Wilner and Sierra Marilyn Riley as his teenaged daughter Violet, who works at Emily’s store. 

The rest of the cast includes Jean Yoon (Kim’s Convenience), Lara Amersey (Operation Nutcracker) and Good Witch alum Kylee Evans (Good Witch). Shooting will begin later this year for a 2025 holiday season premiere.

“We had searched for the right series to blend Christmas with mysteries — two genres our viewers love — and Mistletoe Murders cracked that case to perfection. The enthusiastic audience reaction made the decision to renew the series an easy one,” said Samantha DiPippo, Senior Vice President, Programming, Hallmark Media.  “After the jaw-dropping season finale that left fans asking, Who is Emily Lane?, we look forward to another riveting holiday in Fletcher’s Grove filled with mystery, romance and of course, Christmas.”

“We’re thrilled that Mistletoe Murders is returning for a second season,” continued Jocelyn Hamilton, President, Television, Lionsgate Canada. “Hallmark has been an incredible partner in bringing this series to life, and it’s been such a joy collaborating with the talented team at Headspinner Productions. This renewal is a true testament to the exceptional storytelling and talent that have made the show resonate so deeply with audiences.”

Mistletoe Murders follows Emily, the optimistic shop owner of a year-round Christmas-themed store, Under the Mistletoe. Residing in the tourist town of Fletcher’s Grove, Emily finds herself compelled to investigate local murders. When Emily begins her personal investigations, Detective Sam Wilner (Mooney) begins to wonder if there’s more to Emily than meets the eye.

The series is exec produced by Drew, showrunner Ken Cuperus (Hudson & Rex), Michelle Melanson (The Next Step), and Jocelyn Hamilton (Burden of Truth). Melanie Orr and James Genn direct.

The series comes from Lionsgate Canada and Headspinner Productions, with Lionsgate Television managing international distribution. Mistletoe Murders is adapted from the eponymous Audible Original series starring Cobie Smulders, Raymond Ablack and a full ensemble cast. Three seasons are currently available on Audible.