T.J. Holmes realized he fell in love with Amy Robach in spring 2022 – when he was still married to Marilee Fiebig

T.J. Holmes finally admitted that he fell in love with Amy Robach in spring 2022 — despite still being fully married to Marilee Fiebig.

Robach asked her “GMA3” co-anchor when he realized he was in love with her, and while he first joked he loved her “from birth,” he eventually told the truth.

“[I had] been in love with you in this way when I knew that, and I’m thinking about it in my mind, like when did I know I’m in trouble, like uh-oh, this needs to be addressed. I can’t pinpoint,” Holmes shared on Thursday’s episode of their “Amy and T.J.” podcast.

“Post pandemic, 2020? When was that? Damn, girl.”

T.J. Holmes admitted that he had fallen in love with Amy Robach in spring 2022 – despite still being married to Marilee Fiebig. ajrobach/Instagram “When I thought there was an issue — for me — was 2022, going into spring, certainly summer, but spring of 2022 is when I’d say,” shared Holmes, 46. amyandtjpodcast/Instagram The former “GMA3” co-anchors previously denied having an affair even though now he says he had fallen for Robach months before he filed for divorce from the immigration attorney. amyandtjpodcast/Instagram

The former broadcast journalist said it was “early 2022” but they didn’t start “talking about” their feelings until “much later.”

“When I thought there was an issue — for me — was 2022, going into spring, certainly summer, but spring of 2022 is when I’d say,” Holmes, 46, added.

Robach had nearly finalized her divorce in early December 2022. ajrobach/Instagram

Robach, 51, and Holmes’ secret romance became public knowledge in November 2022, with sources claiming to Page Six that the two had been having an affair for months.

At the time, Robach was married to Andrew Shue while Holmes was wed to Fiebig, 46. Our insiders also told us in December 2022 that the “20/20” host’s divorce from the “Melrose” Place alum, 56, was “almost finalized.”

Holmes, meanwhile, didn’t file for divorce from the immigration lawyer until the end of December 2022 — months after he had fallen in love with Robach.

While Holmes didn’t even file for divorce from Fiebig until the end of December. Getty Images for BET

Despite the questionable relationship timeline, the couple has denied participating in an extramarital affair, which cost them their jobs at ABC.

---

For more Page Six you love…

Listen to our weekly “We Hear” podcast Shop our exclusive merch

---

“To be clear, we were outed as being in a relationship, but everyone else thought we were being outed as adulterers — being outed as cheating on our spouses — and it wasn’t the case,” Holmes claimed during the premiere episode of their podcast.

“We both at that point were in divorce proceedings.” 

Wildly enough, Fiebig and Shue are now dating. Marilee Holmes/Instagram

In a wild twist of fate, Fiebig and Shue are now dating after having bonded over the hurt of their former spouses’ betrayal.

“It turned into something else, and they’re connected over their values. It’s bigger than the affair now,” one insider told us of the new romance.

“They’re not heartbroken and sad,” a second source shared. “Everyone has moved on.”